The St. Louis Cardinals are making waves under the guidance of Chaim Bloom, who has taken the reins as the team’s lead decision-maker.
His strategic focus on bolstering the pitching staff through the draft and trading veterans for younger, cost-controlled arms has set the stage for a promising rebuild. While the Cardinals have been largely successful in this transition, fans are starting to scrutinize the catching position, suggesting it’s time for an upgrade.
The buzz among Cardinals faithful centers on bringing up catching prospect Jimmy Crooks. The idea is to shake up the current catching lineup, which includes Ivan Herrera and Pedro Pages, with Crooks potentially taking over and Pages being phased out as new catching talent emerges.
While Rainiel Rodriguez has caught plenty of attention, it’s Crooks’ offensive prowess in Triple-A Memphis that stands out. Comparing his performance to Pages’ current output, it’s easy to see why fans are eager to see Crooks in the majors.
However, Cardinals fans might need to exercise patience regarding any changes to the catching setup. Pedro Pages, despite some offensive struggles, ranks as the 15th-best catcher in baseball based on fWAR among those with at least 100 plate appearances.
His defensive skills, which have been widely praised, bolster this ranking. Offensively, Pages is 22nd among catchers with a 73 wRC+ and a .208 batting average.
If these numbers persist, Pages could be facing his worst offensive season since entering the majors. Yet, no immediate roster changes seem to be on the horizon.
Cardinals manager Oli Marmol has expressed both enthusiasm for the current catching configuration and excitement about Jimmy Crooks’ future potential. With the Cardinals in a playoff position, it’s hard to find much to complain about, but the desire for a more potent bat than Pages’ is understandable.
Marmol acknowledges Crooks’ potential impact at the plate but emphasizes that Pages’ defensive contributions and preparation don’t always show up in traditional stats. These intangibles have helped the starting rotation exceed expectations, even if Pages’ offensive output can be frustrating at times.
In Memphis, Crooks is evolving into a formidable hitter. While strikeouts remain a concern, he’s reduced his K-rate recently without sacrificing power or discipline.
Through 35 games, Crooks boasts a career-high walk rate of 17.2%, more than double last year’s figure in Triple-A, and he’s already hit 13 homers, nearing his career high. Despite this impressive performance, Crooks will have to wait for his major league call-up.
The Cardinals’ clubhouse chemistry is thriving, with players like Pages, Pozo, and Herrera contributing to the positive atmosphere. As fan expectations shift from a .500 season to playoff aspirations, it’s natural to want the best hitters in the lineup daily. However, the unseen contributions, the ones that don’t fill box scores, may be crucial for this Cardinals team right now.
